Historic Evansville

The definitive site for all things historic in Evansville

Bethany Christian (Old)

Bethany Christian (Old)


Bethany Christian (Old)

View all images of Bethany Christian (Old)

522 W Maryland St, originally 601 E Maryland St
Evansville, IN

Quick Timeline

1899 Church built
1913 Bethany moves to new church
Becomes Mormon church
1956 Mormon church relocates to Olmstead area
c1960 Razed


Southeast corner Jacobs Ave (Edgar St) and Maryland St
District: Jacobsville
Latitude: 37.985452
Longitude: -87.572169
View map of nearby sites



The church dates back to 1891 when it was founded as mission church of First Christian. It purchased property at Maryland and Jacobs but met at a residence at 1006 Mary St temporarily. In 1896, a small cottage was built on the lot.

The congregation was officially organized in 1897 as Bethany Christian.

1898-9 a church building fronting Jacobs Ave was built and dedicated Feb 5, 1899 (old building enlarged?)

The growing church bought a lot on Columbia at the end of Edgar. Ground was broken in 1911, and Bethany moved to its new location April 1913. The Mormon church bought the building in August 1913 and the Church of Jesus Christ worshiped here for years.

In 1956, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints moved to an old brick home at 525 E Olmstead Ave. The Mormons later built a new church in 1961.

Bethany Christian purchased land back? and church was razed c1960


See also Churches / Religion Jacobsville district

Research notes

+ Show research notes